Image Credit: Kin Donelly - flickr
The Institute of Economic Affairs (IEA-Kenya) created a Citizen Alternative Budget to get people involved in Kenya’s national budgeting process.
SETTING THE SCENE —Government budgets are essential tools for ensuring the delivery of critical services like basic education, maternal health, and roads. They are also valued by citizens who want to know that their taxes are being efficiently invested in these services. Unless there is transparency in budgeting, the government will struggle to convince citizens that it is striking the right balance between spending and taxation. Unfortunately, public budgets often fail to serve everyone’s best interests, especially those of marginalized groups, such as women and the poor.
In 2010, Kenya’s declaration of a new consti tution ushered in a fresh financial landscape in the country. The principles of public finance management enshrined in the 2010 Constitution aimed to foster openness and accountabil ity, public participation in the budget process, promotion of an equitable society, and transpa rent financial reporting. With the support of the Think Tank Initiative, the Institute of Economic Affairs (IEA-Kenya) seized this opportunity to ef fectively engage citizens in the budget process in a more participatory way than had been pos sible in the past.
WHAT IEA-KENYA DID —For 20 years, IEAKenya has worked to promote the pluralism of ideas in Kenya through open, active, and informed debate on public policy issues. In 2002, the think tank began an annual process to develop a Citizen Alternative Budget as an avenue for citizens to par ticipate in the budget process. Several months before the release of the national budget each year, IEAKenya holds annual prebudget hea rings and receives proposals from key stakehold ers within the public and private sectors (both corporate and social). Representatives from think tanks, civil society organizations, nongov ernmental organizations, women’s health, educa tion, and other sectors unite to hash out alterna tives. These ideas must, of course, be consistent with the government’s overall objectives, as the Citizen Alternative Budget seeks to influence government decisions by developing alternatives to government policy. IEAKenya synthesizes these suggestions into a memorandum that it shares with the National Treasury for inclusion in the na tional budget.
Once the government’s budget for the fiscal year is released, IEAKenya reviews it to identify any proposals that have been overlooked. The think tank’s feedback is sent to the Treasury and a simplified format is shared in a public forum where key stakeholders in the private and public sectors, members of the media, and the public are invited to attend and participate in the discu ssion. IEAKenya also produces a Budget Guide to help members of Parliament, the public, and the media understand and discuss national budget allocations.
IEA-Kenya has proven effective in getting its pro posals into the national budget and Think Tank Initiative funds have been used to dedicate spe cific research to this process. One example of how IEA-Kenya influenced the government bud get involves a proposal for the taxation of toba cco products. In line with Kenya’s obligations related to the Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC), Kenya committed to implementing a number of tobacco control measures, including favourable tax and price policies targeted at reducing demand for tobacco products. IEAKen ya’s argument was based on research that indi cated exciseinduced increases in tobacco prices cause tobacco consumption to decrease and in the process, increase tobacco taxes and govern ment revenue. This proposal was successfully in cluded in the 2013–2014 federal budget.
THE OUTCOME —IEAKenya has become a house hold name in Kenya with its Citizen Alternative Budgets. While high-profile international financial agencies also draft alternative budgets, they tend to focus on specific areas of interest, whereas IEAKenya’s budget is nationwide and more cohe sive. The Ministry of Finance is currently develop ing a public finance reform strategy and has invited IEAKenya as the only nongovernment institution to participate. Similarly, the Treasury recently asked the think tank to make an alternative pro posal on tax brackets. IEAKenya is also expanding its reach: while until recently the think tank worked on the alternative budget at the national and pro vincial levels, it is now growing to reach Kenya’s 47 counties and will assist these counties in formula ting their own alternative budgets.
For more information on the Institute of Economic Affairs in Kenya visit www.ieakenya.or.ke